Pickled Fish Recipes

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

pickled herrings in a sandwich

These two pickled fish recipes are easily adaptable for other fish of a similar size and nature.

They can be adapted for pickled mackerel or pilchards and the liquid can be cider, pale ale or white vinegar substituted for the ordinary vinegar. 

Experiment with the combinations to develop these recipes to your own taste.

You can ask the fishmonger to clean the fish for you or do it yourself.

You'll probably buy them with the guts out but the head might be on. So cut off the heads and then descale the fish by scraping the blunt side of a knife across the scales. It makes a mess, so do it over newspaper to enable you to catch the scales or you might be finding them stuck on the counter for weeks.

I like to fillet mine, take it off the bone - you'll need a sharp knife and cut in on one side of the backbone, work your blade against the bones. You'll be slow to begin with, but you'll soon speed up and your finished fillets will be much neater.

Wash the fillets when you've finished.

Pickled Mackerel

4 small mackerel
salt and pepper
2 bay leaves
1 tspn allspice
10 peppercorns
1/2 pint (300 ml) wine vinegar

Preheat oven to Gas Mark 2, 310F or 150C

Clean and wash the fish and place them in an ovenproof dish.

Add salt, pepper, bay leaves, allspice, peppercorns, vinegar and add enough water to cover the fish.

Bake, covered, for about an hour.

Leave in the liquor to cool before serving.

Pickled Herrings
8 herrings
1 onion, peeled and cut into rings
2 bay leaves
12 peppercorns, crushed with a rolling pin
1/4 pint (300 ml) cider
1/4 pint (300 ml) wine vinegar

Heat oven to Gas mark 4, 350F, 180C

Wash the herrings and pack them into an ovenproof dish.

Sprinkle over the onion, broken bay leaves, peppercorns. Add the cider and vinegar.

Cover and bake for about 30 minutes.

Allow to cool in the liquor before serving.

Gravad Lax
Gravad Lax - marinated salmon - click here. This recipe is also suitable for mackerel or trout. You need a bit of a leap of faith to make this - trust me, it's a fabulous recipe and really easy to make.

You may also like these recipes

Some of the links on this site include affiliate links, providing Find-a-Seafood-Recipe a small percentage of the sale at no additional cost to you. 

Subscribe to Seafood Recipe News - complete the form below.

Your email address is secure and will *only* be used to send Seafood Recipe News. When you confirm your subscription, you will be taken to a page where you can access your free eCourse. Complete the form and it will arrive over the following five days.

newsletter subscribe image

Pickled Fish Recipes


Pickled fish recipes, mackerel, herrings and salmon

Find out how to do pickled fish recipes, mackerel, herrings and salmon.

Prep Time: 15 minutes

Cook time: 60 minutes

Yield: 4

Main Ingredient: mackerel or herrings, vinegar